Bethel
Bethel
Bethel Church is a charismatic Christian megachurch located in Redding, California. It was founded in 1954 by Bill and Benni Johnson. Over the years, it has grown into one of the largest and most influential churches in the charismatic movement, attracting thousands of attendees from around the world.
Bethel Church is known for its emphasis on supernatural signs and wonders, prophetic ministry, healing, and spiritual renewal. It is part of the broader Bethel School of Supernatural Ministry (BSSM), which offers training in areas such as prophetic ministry, healing, and worship leadership. BSSM has gained international recognition and draws students from various countries seeking to deepen their spiritual walk and ministry skills.
In addition to its local church services and school, Bethel Church is known for its worship music ministry, Bethel Music, which has released numerous albums featuring original songs written and performed by members of the church. Bethel Music has had a significant impact on contemporary Christian music and has a global following.
Bethel Church's teachings and practices have been the subject of both admiration and controversy within Christian circles. While many individuals have been drawn to its emphasis on spiritual experiences and encounters with God, others have raised concerns about its theology, practices, and influence, particularly regarding issues such as spiritual warfare, prosperity theology, and the supernatural.
Bethel Church continues to be a prominent and influential force within the charismatic Christian movement, known for its commitment to worship, supernatural ministry, and empowering believers to walk in their spiritual gifts. Its impact extends beyond its local congregation, reaching a global audience through its ministries, music, and resources.
Bethel & IHOPKC
Bethel Church in Redding, California, and the International House of Prayer in Kansas City (IHOPKC) are both influential organizations within the broader charismatic and evangelical Christian movements. While they are separate entities with distinct leadership, visions, and theological emphases, there are connections between them in terms of shared networks, collaborations, and commonalities in their beliefs and practices.
Both Bethel Church and IHOPKC are known for their emphasis on prayer, worship, prophetic ministry, and supernatural manifestations. They have also played significant roles in promoting charismatic renewal and revival within contemporary Christianity.
There have been instances of collaboration and interaction between Bethel Church and IHOPKC, such as joint conferences, guest speakers, and worship events. Additionally, individuals associated with one organization may have connections or relationships with individuals in the other.
While Bethel Church and IHOPKC are separate entities, they share common ground in their commitment to advancing the Kingdom of God through worship, prayer, and spiritual empowerment. Their collaborations and connections reflect the broader unity and diversity within the charismatic Christian movement.
Bethel & The New Apostolic Reformation (NAR)
Bethel Church in Redding, California, is often associated with the New Apostolic Reformation (NAR) movement, although the extent of its connection to the NAR can be a matter of interpretation and perspective.
The NAR is a loose network of charismatic and evangelical Christian churches, ministries, and leaders that emerged in the late 20th century. It emphasizes the restoration of apostolic ministry, supernatural signs and wonders, spiritual warfare, and the transformation of society according to biblical principles. While the NAR lacks centralized leadership or organizational structure, it has had a significant influence within certain segments of charismatic Christianity.
Bethel Church shares some theological and practical similarities with the NAR, particularly in its emphasis on prophetic ministry, spiritual warfare, and the belief in the ongoing manifestation of spiritual gifts. Additionally, some leaders associated with Bethel Church have connections to the broader NAR movement, and there may be instances of collaboration or interaction between Bethel Church and NAR-affiliated ministries.
However, it's important to note that Bethel Church is an independent organization with its own distinct identity, leadership, and theological emphases. While it may share common ground with the NAR in certain areas, it also maintains autonomy and operates separately from other NAR-affiliated ministries.
While Bethel Church is often associated with the NAR movement due to shared theological perspectives and relationships among leaders, the nature and extent of their connection may vary, and may not be universally recognized or acknowledged by all individuals or organizations within the broader charismatic and evangelical Christian movements.
Bethel Controversies
Bethel Church in Redding, California, has been associated with several controversies over the years, though it's important to note that perceptions of these controversies can vary widely among different individuals and groups. Some of the controversies associated with Bethel Church include:
Theology and Practices: Bethel Church's emphasis on supernatural signs and wonders, prophetic ministry, and spiritual experiences has drawn criticism from some quarters within Christianity. Critics have raised concerns about theological issues such as prosperity gospel teachings, the pursuit of supernatural manifestations, and the promotion of certain practices and beliefs not universally accepted within the broader Christian community.
Healing Ministry: Bethel Church's emphasis on divine healing and miracles has sparked debate and controversy, particularly regarding claims of supernatural healings and the role of faith in physical restoration. Some skeptics have questioned the validity of reported healings and raised ethical concerns about the promotion of faith-based healing practices.
Financial Transparency: Like many large churches and ministries, Bethel Church has faced scrutiny over its finances and stewardship practices. Questions have been raised about the church's financial transparency, accountability, and the allocation of resources, particularly in relation to its extensive ministries, schools, and outreach programs.
Influence and Control: Critics have raised concerns about Bethel Church's influence and control over its members, particularly within the context of its close-knit community and charismatic leadership structure. Some former members and observers have expressed concerns about issues such as authoritarian leadership, groupthink, and the pressure to conform to certain beliefs and practices.
Music Ministry: Bethel Music, the church's worship music ministry, has faced criticism from some quarters for its theological content, style, and influence within the broader Christian music industry. Some critics have raised concerns about the theological messaging of certain songs, as well as the commercialization of worship music and its impact on congregational worship practices.
It's worth noting that while these controversies have attracted attention and debate, Bethel Church also has a large and dedicated following of supporters who affirm its ministry, teachings, and impact. Like any large and influential organization, Bethel Church's controversies are complex and multifaceted, and opinions about the church and its practices can vary widely among different individuals and groups.
Olive Alayne Heiligenthal
The Olive Alayne Heiligenthal incident refers to a highly publicized event involving the two-year-old daughter of Bethel Church worship leader Kalley Heiligenthal. In December 2019, the Heiligenthal family announced on social media that their daughter, Olive Alayne Heiligenthal, had unexpectedly passed away in her sleep.
After her death, members of Bethel Church in Redding, California, held onto her body for several days and publicly prayed for her resurrection, believing that she would be raised from the dead. The family and church leaders encouraged people to pray for Olive's revival, citing biblical examples of Jesus raising the dead and expressing faith in God's power to perform miracles.
The situation garnered significant media attention and sparked discussions within Christian circles about the nature of faith, prayer, and divine intervention. Some individuals expressed support and solidarity with the Heiligenthal family, while others raised concerns about the appropriateness of publicizing and promoting such beliefs and practices, particularly in the context of grieving.
Despite fervent prayers and widespread attention, Olive Heiligenthal was not resurrected, and her passing was ultimately confirmed by the family. The incident prompted reflection and dialogue within the broader Christian community about the complexities of faith, grief, and the pursuit of miracles.
It's important to approach sensitive topics such as death, grieving, and matters of faith with empathy, respect, and understanding, recognizing the deeply personal nature of these experiences and the diversity of beliefs within the Christian tradition.
Grave Soaking
Grave soaking, also known as grave soaking or grave sucking, is a controversial practice associated with certain segments of the charismatic Christian movement. It involves individuals lying on or near the graves of deceased Christian leaders or influential figures in the hope of receiving spiritual impartation or blessings from their anointing.
While there have been reports and rumors circulating about individuals associated with Bethel Church engaging in grave soaking or promoting similar practices, it's essential to approach such claims with caution and discernment. Bethel Church has not officially endorsed or promoted grave soaking as part of its teachings or practices.
In a video conversation, Bill Johnson and Dann Farrelly, two leaders of Bethel Church, explained that they honor and respect the saints of the past who have walked in the power and presence of God. They shared their experiences of visiting places of significance, such as the Upper Room in Israel, or the graves of revivalists like Charles Finney or A.B. Simpson, and how they pray for God to do it again in their generation.
However, they clarified that there was no séance, no calling back the dead, no soaking of anointing, and certainly no straws (not even sustainable ones) present. They also talked about the culture of risk and experimentation that they have in their ministry, and how they try to discern and steward the testimonies of what God has done.
COVID-19
There have been reports and allegations of Bethel Church in Redding, California, violating COVID-19 safety orders and guidelines during the pandemic. Like many religious organizations and businesses, Bethel Church has faced challenges and controversies related to navigating public health restrictions and balancing the desire to continue holding religious services with the need to protect public health and safety.
Some reports have suggested that Bethel Church continued to hold in-person gatherings or events despite local or state orders restricting large gatherings and requiring social distancing measures. These allegations have sparked debate and criticism within the community and beyond, with some individuals expressing concern about the potential risks of spreading COVID-19 through large gatherings.
Bethel Church’s School of Supernatural Ministry, based in Redding, California, was tied to over 120 COVID-19 cases. The school took measures to curb the spread of the virus among faculty and students, including operating at 70% capacity and having freshmen attend classes at the Redding Civic Auditorium. However, the primary source of transmission was found to be off-campus living situations and social interactions outside of school hours.
See:
It's important to note that responses to COVID-19 have varied widely among religious organizations, and Bethel Church is not the only religious institution to face scrutiny or criticism for its handling of the pandemic. Like other organizations, Bethel Church has had to navigate complex and evolving public health guidelines and make difficult decisions about how to conduct its religious services and activities in light of the pandemic.
It's also worth noting that Bethel Church has implemented various safety measures and modifications to its operations in response to COVID-19, including offering online services, implementing social distancing protocols, and encouraging mask-wearing and other preventive measures when in-person gatherings have occurred.
The issue of COVID-19 safety compliance within religious institutions like Bethel Church reflects broader debates and challenges surrounding public health, religious freedom, and community responsibility during the pandemic.
Sean Feucht
Sean Feucht is a Christian worship leader, musician, and activist known for his involvement in the worship music movement and his passion for evangelism and social justice causes. He is associated with Bethel Church in Redding, California, and has been a part of Bethel Music, the church's worship music ministry.
Feucht gained prominence within Christian circles for his involvement in leading worship at Bethel Church and contributing to Bethel Music's albums and projects. He has released several albums of his own worship music and has been involved in leading worship at various Christian events and conferences around the world.
In addition to his music ministry, Feucht has also become known for his activism and outreach efforts, particularly in the areas of missions, humanitarian aid, and social justice. He has been involved in organizing and leading worship gatherings and prayer events in locations around the world, including areas affected by conflict, poverty, and natural disasters.
Feucht's connection to Bethel Church has led to speculation and controversy within Christian circles, particularly among those who have concerns about certain beliefs or practices associated with Bethel Church or the broader charismatic movement. However, Feucht's ministry and activism extend beyond his association with Bethel Church, and he has become known as a prominent figure within contemporary Christian worship music and evangelicalism more broadly.
Sean Feucht Controversies
Sean Feucht has attracted controversy and criticism from some quarters within the Christian community for various beliefs and practices associated with his ministry and activism. Some of the controversies surrounding Sean Feucht include:
Association with Bethel Church: Feucht's association with Bethel Church in Redding, California, has led to criticism from individuals who have concerns about certain beliefs or practices associated with Bethel Church or the broader charismatic movement. Some critics have raised concerns about Bethel Church's emphasis on supernatural manifestations, prophetic ministry, and teachings related to spiritual warfare and divine healing.
Response to COVID-19: Feucht has faced criticism for his response to COVID-19 and his advocacy for large-scale worship gatherings and events during the pandemic. Some have accused him of disregarding public health guidelines and endangering public safety by organizing and participating in large gatherings without adequate COVID-19 safety precautions.
Political Activism: Feucht's involvement in political activism and his support for certain political causes and candidates have generated controversy within Christian circles. Some individuals have raised concerns about Feucht's alignment with particular political ideologies or parties and his use of his platform to promote partisan agendas.
Missionary Work: Feucht's missionary work and outreach efforts in areas affected by conflict, poverty, and natural disasters have drawn both praise and criticism. While many commend Feucht for his commitment to serving those in need and sharing the gospel in challenging environments, others have raised questions about the effectiveness and sustainability of his approach and the potential impact of his actions on local communities.
Theological Views: Feucht's theological views and teachings on subjects such as worship, revival, and evangelism have been a source of debate and disagreement within the Christian community. Some critics have questioned the theological soundness of Feucht's teachings and expressed concerns about potential theological errors or distortions.
Sean Feucht's ministry and activism have sparked debate and controversy within Christian circles, with supporters praising his passion for worship and evangelism and critics raising concerns about his beliefs, practices, and actions. Like many prominent figures within Christianity, Feucht's influence and impact are subject to differing interpretations and evaluations among believers.
Sean Feucht & Trump
Sean Feucht has been connected to former President Donald Trump through his involvement in political activism and events. Feucht has expressed support for Trump and has been known to attend and participate in Trump rallies and events. He has also been vocal about his political beliefs and has advocated for causes aligned with Trump's agenda.
Additionally, Feucht has been involved in organizing worship events and prayer gatherings in support of Trump and his administration. He has used his platform as a musician and activist to mobilize Christians to pray for and support Trump's policies and initiatives.
Feucht's connection to Trump has led to criticism from some quarters within the Christian community, particularly among those who have concerns about Trump's leadership or his alignment with certain political ideologies. However, Feucht's support for Trump reflects broader divisions and debates within American Christianity regarding the relationship between faith and politics.
Sean Feucht For Congress
Sean Feucht ran for Congress in the 2020 United States elections. He sought the Republican nomination for California's 3rd Congressional District, which encompasses areas in the northern part of the state, including portions of Sacramento and its surrounding counties.
Feucht's candidacy attracted attention due to his prominence as a Christian worship leader, musician, and activist. He campaigned on a platform that included conservative values, support for religious freedom, pro-life advocacy, and opposition to what he characterized as government overreach and infringement on individual liberties.
While Feucht's congressional bid garnered support from some conservative Christians and Republican voters, he ultimately did not win the Republican primary for California's 3rd Congressional District. Despite his defeat, Feucht's candidacy highlighted the intersection of faith, politics, and activism within contemporary American Christianity.
Redding City Council Takeover
Bethel Church, an 11,000-member megachurch based in Redding, California, has gained significant influence in the local community over the years. As of the elections in November, members of Bethel Church hold the majority on the Redding City Council.
The church’s influence in the city council began with Julie Winter, a Bethel Church elder, who was already serving on the Redding City Council. In the November elections, two more Bethel members, Tenessa Audette and Jack Munns, were elected to the council. This resulted in Bethel members holding a majority of seats on the 5-member council.
The elections were highly competitive, with six evangelicals — three Bethel members and three members of The Stirring church, which has connections to Bethel — among 10 candidates running for three open seats. Despite the competition, the Bethel members were successful, leading to their current majority on the council.
As for the intent behind this, it’s important to note that Bethel Church is committed to Seven Mountain dominionism, a philosophy that encourages Christians to influence seven major spheres of society: church, family, education, government, media, arts, and commerce. Pastor Bill Johnson, the leader of Bethel Church, has written about this mandate in his book “Invading Babylon: The 7 Mountain Mandate,” where he describes the church’s role in society.
While it’s clear that Bethel Church has a significant influence in Redding, it’s also important to note that the city council is still a democratic institution with checks and balances in place. The extent to which the church’s majority on the council will impact local governance is yet to be seen.